Skip to content


Pilgrim Manor is a vibrant five-star senior care community located in Plymouth, Indiana, dedicated to providing first-rate healthcare services to the seniors of Marshall County and surrounding areas. With over 50 years of senior care experience, we strive to bring a superior level of care and attention to each resident, focusing on improving quality of life and restoring independence. We offer seniors second-to-none skilled nursing care, rehab services including physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, and individual therapy, respite care, adult day services, and hospice care. Whatever type of assistance is required, Pilgrim Manor has the compassionate care your loved one needs to flourish.

Our facility accepts a variety of payment options including Medicare, Medicaid, private pay, Anthem, and United Health Care. Pilgrim Manor’s experienced admissions team understands that financial planning is critical when it comes to senior care. We know that knowledge and awareness is key when it comes to financial arrangements, and we are always prepared to assist you in constructing the best plan for your senior.

Our family-owned campus is situated on five beautiful acres and offers a true country setting in the city. We are conveniently located near Centennial Park, home of our community’s annual Blueberry Festival! We’re also only three miles away from Saint Joseph Hospital, assuring that any urgent medical needs can be addressed quickly. Our community is easily accessible from any direction, allowing for frequent and easy visits from family and friends.

Pilgrim Manor’s building was designed and constructed with a special emphasis on resident privacy and dignity. Your loved one will be safe, secure, and comfortable in our recently remodeled facility, including 78 rooms. Over half of these rooms are private suites that include spacious built-in showers. Large and luxuriously common areas are strategically placed around the interior and exterior areas of our immaculate facility. This design provides families with adequate privacy while visiting their loved ones.

Seniors can enjoy many special features and amenities when they become a resident of Pilgrim Manor. Residents have the opportunity to participate in various social activities on our campus! They can take part in crafts, puzzles, games, and movies, listen to community speakers at our monthly Breakfast Club. Residents can also experience the joy of the holidays such as when children come to trick-or-treat during Halloween.

From skilled nursing and rehabilitation to respite care and other accommodations, Pilgrim Manor is the perfect senior care community for your loved one. With over 50 years of senior care management experience, we promise you peace of mind. Contact us today to discuss our service offerings! 574-936-9943. When you’re at Pilgrim Manor, you’re home.


Meet our team

Susan Wagers
Director of Nursing

Susan Wagers, has been with Pilgrim Manor Since 1981, and brings compassion and expert care to both residents and staff.

Susan Wagers, has been with Pilgrim Manor Since 1981, and brings compassion and expert care to both residents and staff.

Pilgrim Manor’s skilled nurses carefully follow your physician’s instructions, administering care orders, monitoring your health and assuring that the care needed is provided. Care plans are updated regularly, to accommodate your changing needs. Skilled nurses are onsite 24 hours a day.

Whether short or long-term care is needed, our team provides quality, individualized care 24 hours a day. A comprehensive care plan is individualized and designed to outline the needs and goals of care for each resident. This care plan is updated on a regular basis and updated regularly to meet the individual needs of each resident.

At Pilgrim Manor, we have a group of compassionate caring staff who go above and beyond for each of our residents and many of our residents are much more than residents, they are part of our Pilgrim Manor family and we are proud to be serving them each day.

Melodie Overmyer
Social Service Director

On board since 2002. In her role as Social Service Director, Melodie can assist with the coordination of your transition to Pilgrim Manor and welcome you and your loved ones.

As Services Director/Admissions Coordinator since 2002, Melody has assisted with the coordination of your transition to Pilgrim Manor and advocating for your loved ones. Feel free to contact Melodie at or call her at (574) 936-9943.

Accommodation 2
Accommodations 1
West Dining
East Lounge 2

Pilgrim Manor Rehabilitation and Nursing Services | Privacy Policy

(574) 936-9943